Blog

New Student Cities Take Money From Local Economies

typical rented student house in sheffieldIn the news today I saw an article written for (or possibly by) a property news web site.The article was about how students can be an ‘untapped source’ for investment opportunity.

I found myself quite irritated by the article which stated inaccurate facts and was based purely around one set of figures from a single study of a very minimal amount of target research. That is very lazy article writing.

Some Quotes

Quote 1:

According to recently released statistics, 88% of Britain’s 1.2 million undergraduate university students live in flats and houses rented from private sector landlords.

There are in fact over 1.9 million UNI students. Out of 1.9 million students only 1,100 were surveyed and this is supposed to be a balanced snapshot?

Quote 2:

A survey conducted by AccommodationforStudents.com, with the participation of 1,100 university students, shows that most undergraduates prefer flats or homes with two bedrooms and with a relatively spacious, eat-in kitchen.

Well! blow me down with a feather, people prefer living in spacious accommodation. What a finding. (Wonder who paid for this report??)

Governments Step In (again)

Over the last couple of years there has been a rash of new student ‘cities’ being built by local councils.In my view this has had the effect of deadening the local economy in those areas. Students bring money into an area. They shop locally, use buses/ trains, need accommodation and entertainment. In short they spend money.

To me it s no surprise that local councils have looked at this untapped source of revenue and decided they want a piece of it. Effectively, by building huge tower blocks for students to live in, and providing on site shops, wi-fi and entertainment, they have removed a huge chunk of revenue from the local econonomy and into their own coffers.

Sheffield

sheffield student accommodationA friend of mine in Sheffield (a huge university town) says many landlords are having to sell up because they now can’t rent their properties. These properties are very large old Victorian villa style-not easy to sell in any market. Usually they are 6 bedrooms or more, like the one pictured at the top of this post.

The demand for this type of house is limited. Many are landlords are going bankrupt. It has also put people out of work as landlords employed cleaners, gardeners, builders and removal firms. Lots of them are really noticing the lack of work in an already depressed area. The council also made the new student blocks cheaper than local rentals-effectively forcing out local landlords.

Packing them into expensive halls of residence neither gives them the experience of independent living, nor integration with thriving communities. It will create student ghettos. Lets be clear here, once again this is about councils lining their own pockets. It’s not about helping the wider community at all by ‘removing student ghettos from the streets.’ as was quoted by a prominent MP recently. This is NIMBY in action. (Not in my back yard.)

New Legislation Overturned

There are over 100,000 properties in the UK’s professional private rented sector. After 6 April 2010 the government set in motion that planning permission would be needed if a landlord wants to rent what has been a family house or flat to three or more unrelated people such as nurses, students, young professionals, immigrant workers, a family with a lodger and even the elderly. This would have been the final nail in the coffin for student landlords in the private rented sector. The new coalition govt says it will not happen. Thank god for some sense at least.

**UPDATE**Since this post was written, the local council in Sheffield is forcing the removal of students out of their previous areas by not allowing planning permission  or conversion to any form of multiple housing or flats. They are attempting to get those huge houses back as single dwellings. Our question is this: Where is the market for that style of property now, who will buy them?


LIKE THIS POST? THEN PLEASE SHARE IT WITH OTHERS!

Click Any Of The Buttons Below- or Click Above Right To Tweet It now!

Dont Be Shy! We Would Love Your Comments too-And We Always Respond.Thanks!
by CTA


  • http://www.robcameron.co.uk/ Rob Cameron

    Hi Roberta (@robertaward), whilst I have no background in property I believe your observations to be more accurate than those of the report. Having been through academic programmes at 3 universities, I have seen a significant growth in campus based accomodation for students and the development continues a pace.

    • http://www.mypropertymentor.co.uk/ Roberta Ward

      Thanks Rob (@robjcameron)In Sheffield, where I mentioned above, it has decimated the local community to a huge extent. The local council have buit 6 blocks around the city and have forced many folks out of business. My brother is in removals and had contracts with lots of local landlords, his business is now on a knife edge. I dont doubt this is happening all over the UK as councils seek once more to fleece local communities of any cash they can get their grubby hands on.Lets not forget, they also have HUGE marketing power too, making it even more difficult for landlords to survive and compete.
      When there are so many homes required for welfare people, why are they sticking their nose into students. Would it not have made more sense to use the new blocks for social housing and actually help people instead?

  • http://twitter.com/jamescoyne James Coyne

    As I recently graduated, I've experienced both tower blocks and shared rental accomodation. In my personal opinion these tower blocks are depressing and unkept by the student population. Although they had cleaners, sick, takeaway boxes and bottle regularly frequented the halls and stairwells.
    And do they add to the local economy? Isn't the average maintenance loan around £6,000 a year? Even if my quoted statistic is slightly off, this is considerably less than the working wage and the majority of the student expenditure is spent on alcohol, economy food and takeaways.
    Although my arguement is slightly condeming of student life, my point is to urge students that the quality of life is greater in rental properties than tower blocks that look like prisons.

    • http://www.mypropertymentor.co.uk/ Roberta Ward

      Thanks James (@jamescoyne) Its really good to get a perspective from someone who has been there and done that so to speak. It hard to convince students that an older style property in the community is going to be better than a sparkling new one right near/ on campus. You also get a service from landlords and some form of flexilbility. Granted, not all landlords are good, but the majority are pretty good from what I see.
      Thanks for commenting.

Content Protected Using Blog Protector By: PcDrome.

Password Reset

Please enter your e-mail address. You will receive a new password via e-mail.